Movies are both a powerful and very modern way of storytelling. In this post we’ll talk some on the topic of how to be wise and guard our hearts and minds with regard to movies. In the next post we will look at how movies can be used positively to stir us to think on what is true and God honoring. For us to understand how to best appreciate their benefits and be guarded against their drawbacks, let’s start with the basics and think about how movies are both similar and different from the stories told long ago.
Entertainment through the telling of stories goes back for thousands of years in human history. Oral traditions in civilizations from the past carried along tales from generation to generation, and each new generation would enjoy with delight the unique characters, settings, and plot of each story told. And even back then at least these two questions could be asked: “What is the purpose of the story?” and “What does the storyteller want me to believe?” Some stories are crafted very intentionally, and some less so, but many stories have a purpose or a goal in mind for the one telling the story. They could be told for the purpose of encouragement, or to remind people of their heritage, or to shape the way the listener thinks about some topic. Stories can carry more purpose and intended impact on the audience than just simply that they are a form of entertainment.
In older times, if a storyteller wanted to obtain a particular impact on their audience through the telling of a story they could do so in a number of ways. They could adjust the content of the story, they could change the way they told it verbally, or they could add presentation to the story through visual cues. Much has changed from older times, and so also has the ability for a storyteller to achieve their desired impact on an audience. From actors on the stage of a play to early motion pictures and beyond, visual and audio stimulation through storytelling has changed dramatically.
When a person watches a movie, especially in the theater environment, their senses are often so overwhelmed by the barrage of stimulants that they are no longer conscious of all the information they are digesting or the impact the film is actually having on them. One example of this kind of stimulation would be the usage of low-frequency sounds during some films to cause the moviegoer to feel anxious or afraid, even though the noise is imperceptible to human hearing. With tools like these and many others at the modern storyteller’s disposal, it means there is even more wisdom in asking the questions “What is the purpose of the story?” and “What does the storyteller want me to believe?”
But why are those two questions important to ask both in past times and present? Why does it matter for a person to know the purpose of a story and what the storyteller is trying to convince them through the tale? Because not every storyteller has the best interests of the listener in mind, and movies can have a profound impact on our thoughts, beliefs, and emotions. God has told us, and human history has confirmed, that humanity is fallen. From the time of Genesis 3 and the fall of human beings into moral corruption we have seen time and time again that human hearts are simply not pure, and therefore the hearts of those who craft movies are not pure either. On top of this, we also live in a broken world, where the demonic realm still has profound influence (Ephesians 6:12) and Satan still deceives the nations (Revelation 20:3, 8). This does not make all movies evil in and of themselves, but it does mean that we should be cautious of expecting that what we are receiving is always morally neutral. By contrast, everything that God tells us is true (Proverbs 30:5), pure (Psalm 12:6), and profitable for us to hear (2 Timothy 3:16).
God also instructs us through the apostle Paul that we should be careful to set our minds on what is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, excellent, and worthy of praise (Philippians 4:8). This doesn’t mean there is no place for the enjoyment of a fictitious story, but even stories with elements that are fictitious must touch on our reality at some point and what they say about our reality matters. Consider how the Lord of the Rings series speaks truth to the reality of fallen humanity through its portrayal of the corrupt desires for the ring, or conversely how What Dreams May Come speaks falsely by representing God as distant and passively interested in the affairs of humanity. More subtly, consider how a film like Night at the Museum portrays life in the midst of a divorced marriage as quite functional, despite the reality that most families with divorce operate with dysfunction and hurt, or how the movie La La Land does not fairly represent the turmoil of relationship opportunities lost.
Whatever the movie, let us strive to be more than just passive onlookers and instead let’s keep our minds in the game, as the movies we watch are capable of more than just entertaining us.